Why we can’t help the NHS without saving social care

Julie Green, Dementia Specialist at Broomfield Hospital*, explains why health and social care go hand in hand. Join our campaign to fix dementia care.

social care and health care

This month, the government promised to give the NHS more money to manage winter pressures. I know I speak for many when I say that this is welcome.

But with services in the community so stretched, more and more people are being admitted to hospital at crisis point and need our help. Many of these admissions would be avoidable if there were responsive services available and more adequate care provision in the home.

Trapped in hospital beds

Up and down the country, hospital staff like me are working tirelessly to give patients the care and support they need to get better. This extra funding will go some way over the next few months to help us manage, but it is not enough to truly reduce the pressure our health service faces.

In particular, we're seeing the growing problem of people with dementia trapped in hospital beds when they are well enough to leave. The sad fact is they're not able to go home or back into the community because appropriate support isn’t available to care for them. Many need specialist rehabilitation or recovery time.

Being in hospital longer than you have to be isn’t good for anyone’s health. But it is even worse for vulnerable, frail people with dementia. Even with the very best nursing, wards can be stressful and noisy places. People who remain in hospital for months at a time are at an increased risk of infections, such as pneumonia or a urinary tract infection. They might also lose their mobility or continence.

Most importantly, every day a person with dementia is away from their own home their chance of returning to their previous functional ability decreases.

Years of cuts to social care

Many of our patients then have no alternative but to go to a care home, sometimes against their will. This is because even the maximum care package means patients are left alone at home for upwards of 18-20 hours each day. This is both heartbreaking on a human level but an outrage from a cost perspective.

The hospital works hard to get people well again so they can return to their own home as soon as they can. But years of cuts to the funding of social care have had a knock-on effect on the NHS.

Not only that, there are fewer places than ever in care homes and specialist nursing homes. There are also less professionals providing home care to those in need. It's common for me to nurse people with dementia in our hospital for several weeks after they are well enough to leave while they wait for a bed in a specialist care home that can meet their needs. This means that people who need help to leave hospital have nowhere to turn to.

This particularly affects people with dementia because they tend to have more complex needs. But often people with dementia are turned away because their care costs more and care providers don’t have the money to give them the support they need.

fix social care

So what does this mean for the NHS?

This means that people with dementia could end up spending weeks or months in hospital when they shouldn’t be there. It’s frustrating because we know this may lead to a progression of their dementia, but there’s very little we can do.

We know social services are stretched and that local authorities are doing their best, but without more money for care what can they do? Meanwhile, it’s also hard because there are so many more patients that need our care – and the limited hospital beds we have should be available for those that are acutely ill or require surgery.

We want to ensure everyone in hospital is safe. But we know that hospitals are not safe places for people with dementia due to the impact it can have on their cognition and function. It’s an impossible situation; trying to provide care to more and more patients, knowing that many won’t be able to get the ongoing care they need to be able to go home.

What needs to happen

The money the government promised this month may at best help to patch up some issues in hospitals this winter. But it won’t speed up the discharge of the thousands of people stuck in hospital who are ready to leave.

The most useful thing the government could do now is put more money into social care, especially facilitating discharge from hospital. This would mean people with dementia can get back to where they feel comfortable, while ensuring we can look after others who need urgent help to get better.

The government can’t continue to see health and social care as separate, because without one, the other will crumble.

*Personal views are expressed by Julie Green

Join our campaign

Unite with us to fix dementia care and help us to campaign for change

Think this page could be useful to someone? Share it:


Add a comment

I agree entirely with you that only Medical Cases should be in Hospital Wards, & discharged as soon as possible . The Local Government Social Care system is under intolerable pressure as we all know . However NHS has its own funds which are " Needs Tested" & not subject to any Financial Assessment . Dementia is a qualifying " Primary Health Need", & Care should be funded via Continuing Healthcare provisions , if sufficiently advanced.
I am told it costs around £850 daily to keep someone in a Hospital Bed. Privately funded Care 24/7 costs around £1000 per week to look after people in their own Home. The huge savings would make NHS more efficient plus a Home environment is preferable for many people with Dementia in my opinion.
If the Patient health is such that a Nursing Home has to be chosen then NHS are able to pay their fees direct under the same long term Care provisions.
Assessments can be made on the Ward via Critical Care Units & the finance via the local Clinical Commissioning Group . Ideally Families would be involved in all these decisions .
My website provides a lot of advice for Families , Carers & Professionals on https://continuinghealthcare.wordpress.com/

Best wishes . Peter Garside

This is helpful

Thanks for highlighting this Julie. It's something I'm all too well aware of through my work with the hospital befriending service via the Alzheimer's Society. Sadly the government don't seem to realise that the bottom line is that it would actually cost less in the long run to give people the care they need at home, rather than in hospital. A win-win situation if only they could see it.

This is helpful
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.