Personal Independence Payment assessments are failing people with dementia

Alzheimer's Society are calling for an end to reassessment for Personal Independence Payments (PIP) for people affected by dementia.

For some time now we have called for an end to reassessment for Personal Independence Payments (PIP) for people affected by dementia. PIP claims are reviewed periodically, this is both wasteful for the system and distressing for the individual. We want to see an acknowledgement that dementia is a degenerative condition - the situation does not improve with time.

Personal Independence Payments

Recognising dementia as a degenerative condition

We encourage people with dementia to live independently and offer support to enable them to live a full life. However, this often requires a huge amount of effort from the individual. Short periods of improvement do not mean that someone’s condition has stopped having a major impact on their life. An individual can do many things to live well, the fact remains that dementia is a degenerative condition.

PIP is not paid because someone has a specific condition, disability or diagnosis, but because of the impact it has on their life. Some people it seems are penalised for doing all they can to manage that impact and to minimise it where possible.

What does a PIP assessment involve?

The PIP assessment looks at 12 day-to-day activities, such as preparing a meal, dressing and mobility (for example, planning and following journeys independently). The number of points scored in each of these 12 ‘descriptors’ determines whether you are eligible.

The Department for Work and Pensions look at the individual's initial claim form, assessment evidence and reports from the face-to-face assessment. For people living with dementia this can present real problems.

Urgent need for a better understanding of dementia

We heard from a person living with dementia who became distressed in her face to face assessment and requested a break feeling overwhelmed and intimidated. The assessor told the woman to ‘pull herself together and get on with it’. Another woman was told ‘I don’t believe you have dementia’. These are examples of a failure on the part of some assessors to make appropriate provision for people who need extra support in the assessment.

The people carrying out face to face assessments on behalf of the DWP to inform the DWP Decision Makers (DM) are the Independent Assessment Service (formally ATOS). We believe both the assessors and the DMs need a much better understanding of how dementia affects people’s lives.

Improving the quality of assessments

For some time now, Alzheimer’s Society has been keen to work with the Independent Assessment Service (formerly ATOS) to use information we provided about the types of dementia that affect younger people, and how those people might present at an assessment, and have offered to work in partnership with them.

Now, with issues around dementia and the PIP assessment receiving public attention, they have approached us to discuss ways in which we can contribute to their training programme for assessors, including providing specialist information about the many ways dementia can affect someone’s life. This is a positive step, and we will work hard to ensure this leads to real improvement.

Advice on taking a PIP assessment for a person with dementia

If possible take someone with you to the assessment for support, and to discuss what it was like afterwards. It helps to provide as much supporting evidence as you can instead of relying only on the form and assessment.

Ask people involved in your care who understand the condition’s impact on your daily life, such as healthcare professionals, to contribute. Explain that you need this information to support a claim for PIP. Ask for a letter explaining how dementia affects your day-to-day life in particular, not just general information about the condition. This doesn’t need to be recent, just from within the last two years and still relevant. It is worth checking whether the professional will charge you a fee for this.

Further information

CAB and Age UK can support people with a PIP applications and wider benefits checks.

You can also contact our National Dementia Helpline for support or advice about dementia.

Think this page could be useful to someone? Share it:


Add a comment

This is criminal. After your own qualified Dr referes you to an Ageing qualified Consultant who then refers you to a qualified neurologist consultant who carries out a brain scan at a General Hospital and agrees with the General Dr and the Ageing consultant that you ate Dementia and prescribes tablets. Who is a PIP assessor to disagree with this qualified persons findings?

This is helpful

I have a assessment and it is making me stressed out it driving me nuts I am scared I will lose it as I get so worked up I will end up cursing losing my temper

This is helpful

Do try and take a family member or friend with you if going for PIP assessment and do emphasis the difference between a good and bad day.
This is particularly relevant in replies to the 12 day to day activities. Mention ovens and taps left on, losing things etc.
Do not be bullied.

This is helpful

are we a dementia friendly country or not and do the officials by now not understand what is happening in a persons life when they have been diagnosed with some thing so dramatic life altering on a day to day basis who knows how the person is copes and understands patience can and I am sure is in short supply on both sides under the circumstances there is no way of training people how to handle and deal with these circumstances each are individual as the person so training can not follow a set down rule but must be flexible

This is helpful
Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.